Category talk:Quidditch players

Incorrect usage?

 * NOTE: Before I click "publish" for what I wrote, there were 316 pages in this category; I've just identified two causes of it (category to be automatically added when placing specific templates;) will make adjustment and see how it helps the situation. Perhaps upon fixing, the number would go straight down, and in that case, I might have to search for pages that actually need this category and put them back. We'll see.

A little concerned upon seeing the seemingly less filtered usage of this category; for example, Category:Greenhouses is one of the many subcategories of Category:Hogwarts locations, any articles categorized in Category:Greenhouses would not have to also be categorized in Category:Hogwarts locations, etc. Category:Quidditch players has subsections that basically should be the filters; if you are a Beater/Chaser/Keeper/Seeker/Quidditch Captain, it automatically means you are a Quidditch player, so there's no reason for a page to have both a subcategory and the category of 1 level above.

Unless a new subcategory similar to Category:Unknown House but in this case, designated for Quidditch players of unknown positions, (for the record, I'm NOT suggesting this option,) ideally, this broader category (Category:Quidditch players) should only display those that fitted that particular description , for those articles would not fit into any of the subcategories, and with no other way to clearly see this batch of players.

Andre Egwu, until specified later on, would be an example to otherwise fit into this category; Arnold Vogler, Dai Llewellyn, Goodwin Kneen, and Gwenog are also examples that're appropriate to stay (individuals found on the navigation template.) Bush, Erica J. and James (Hufflepuff Quidditch player) would also fit (randomly hit jackpot)

-- S a m m m ✦✧ (talk) 20:34, September 13, 2018 (UTC)