Harry Potter Wiki:Featured articles nominations/First year

{{archive
 * result=Not Promoted
 * sig=--{{User:Matoro183/sig2}} 01:14, 16 January 2009 (UTC)
 * discussion=

First Year (0 votes for, 3 against)
I decided to nominate a better article, as I write about this article at like 10pm at night!Yasmine2 }}
 * Oppose: No references. And it having too many images that had no-relevance to the topic. The article is for "First Year" (in general), not Harry Potter's 1st year... although i agree that it may help to describe the important events may happen during a First Year of a Hogwarts student. Another reason why i opposed is because it is not a general article to be discuss or has been discussed in the series unlike "Order of the Phoenix", i recommend "Hogwarts" article instead. --You-Know-Who 07:39, 11 January 2009 (UTC)
 * Oppose: Very cluttered with far too many images, not referenced, songs are not properly formatted, and "Harry's first year" section is sloppily written, with all kinds of grammatical errors. The person who nominated this article hasn't even given a supporting vote. Oread 15:58, 11 January 2009 (UTC)
 * Sorry about the first year article but i am nominating a better atricle right about now.
 * Oppose: This article is filled with grammar mistakes and too many pictures for such a short article. It is not the type of article that should be promoted to FA status. Iluvgracie129 01:10, 12 January 2009 (UTC)