User talk:Mafalda Hopkirk/Ideas

Nice idea, but I wonder about labelling the spells as positive or negative. I would consider all spells the same (except obvious Dark Magic), and only the employment of them would make them positive or negative. Perhaps defensive and offensive magic?

Also, since we are treating the films and games as canon (although not as high as the books) I would scrub the non-canon section and put it in the main article. Tag each spell with a reference stating its source so we know where it comes from. i can help with that if you want. - Cavalier One ( Wizarding Wireless Network ) 17:53, 13 December 2007 (UTC)