You can only guess once per riddle (doesn't apply to five-riddle specials)
A new riddle is posted every day at 9:40 am PST
The first person to answer correctly will get a point to their house
Don't look up anything to help you answer
You can only score three points every week (resets Sunday)
If a house is winning by 5+ pts, the extra points they receive will be given to another house of the solver’s choice
Click here for more details (this leads to a document which is viewed anonymously)
I was part of a set that had a twin,
And I was removed, making it incomplete,
But it was later entirely replaced by another,
I played my role to keep them safe,
But ended up working against myself,
What am I?
Hints: This is not a repeat riddle. This was in the first half of the main series and movies. This was first mentioned in PoA.. This is not sentient and solid. This does not have a wiki page. This is not a type of food. There are more than one of the thing in general, but I'm looking for a specific one. This object was removed to help a plan. The way I was interpreting this there are only two sets, but there are more than one of the set in general. This has an owner, and he is male, and was of age when Harry first met him. Harry did not interact with this that we know of, but he could've. Usually there are only 2 sets of this. This has been at Hogwarts. Not the entire riddle was from one book. This has been alive at some point but isn't currently alive. The entire riddle is in the main series.
The answer was part of a set, and the set had a twin. The twin has something very similar to the answer but isn't the exact one. The twin is similar in appearance. The twins are usually in close proximity of each other.
They could no longer play their role properly because of somewhere they had been.
The replacement was very similar to the set it replaced
The 'them' in line 4 is the owner.
The removal was the reason that it worked against itself.
I'm excited... Good luck!