I don't think the resurrection stone brings back anyone at all. I know it sounds strange, but hear me out. When Harry was going to Voldemort at the Battle of Hogwarts, he uses the resurrection stone to bring back his parents, Remus, and Sirius. He asks them about death, and it almost seems like they encourage him to go die. I don't think it was them at all, only a "mirror image" of them. If they were actually there, I think they would tell him to fight back. They would tell him to be strong. Same with the second Brother, the stone brought back his dead fiance. He committed suicide to be with her. I think that death created the stone to lure people to death with an illusion of their loved ones.
24,093
pages
ALL POSTS
Yaa that was his trick to kill all the three brother
yes. nothing can bring people back from the dead fully. it makes sense that Death would like to trick them into coming with him into his arms, because Dumbledore said that no spell, potion, enchanted item or curse, can bring any living being that has died back into the world.
@PranavMirsha2 His mothers love was sort of like one of his second live. it wasn’t the stone. he dropped on his way to face voldemort.
Death was cunning so I think that was a trip for harry to be killed as it happened with the mid peverrel brother.
Good idea... that totally makes sense! I mean, Death did take the second brother like a day after he gave him the stone but you do you.
Cool
It never came into my head before that it was only a trick!!!
If we postulate that Death itself created the stone, it's a pertinent theory. I like it. a lot ^^
What i understand from ur theory is that the loved one brought back with the harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Resurrection_Stone has only the same appearance as the actual spirit, and this "fake-ghost" -let's call it- tries to lure the user of the stone to die (if that's what u meant)
Well, idk, i believe it brings the actual spirit since it's not what that fake ghost says that pushes the user to 'go die' but rather the longing: what happened to harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Cadmus in harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/The_Tale_of_the_Three_Brothers ...
<Finally, the second brother, driven mad with hopeless longing, killed himself so as truly to join her.> _the harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/The_Tales_of_Beedle_the_Bard _
And, for harry's parents, i believe they were actually encouraging him , i mean they can't tell him not to go to Voldemort ! He has to, that WAS fighting back ! It was the only way, it was the right choice. If they said the opposite then I'll be suspicious.
But still, u do have a point when u say the stone lures people to die that was the harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Death 's aim in the story, it was only harry who used it as a relief instead of a cause of death as far as we know.
And, i think u might have a point about their behavior what i mean is Cadmus's fiancé was described "sad and cold" in the story, but honestly i don't expect any brought-back ^^spirit^^ to be enthusiastic and start acting normal like...death is tragic isn't it...
(Edited by Hermione-Dromeda)
That actually makes a lot of sense, also, welcome to the best HP fandom there is you've made a great choice joining