They both seem fake. If they interogated barty crouch jr with veritaserum, why won't they use it on harry? And liquid luck, why does NO ONE except slughorn make it, i mean????? Oh! And snape will probably have the ingredients to make and use it, (proof in OoTP when he gave umbridge) why not use it on the death eaters like lucius malfoy and liquid luck, why didn't every one use it so that no one dies. And snape is a POTIONS MASTER why doesn't he have more ingredients to make it????