WHAAA? Why is there no love for dobby, He was a slave for most of his life got had to brutally beat himself up if he made the smallest mistake, and once he finally had a good life he only got a few years and the got a knife thrown into him. At least Fred always had loving friends and family by his side, he had a bond so strong with his twin that nothing could break it. Dobby had it way worse

Tru... but I feel bad for Fred too. It was him or Fred.

-searches- How to vote two options on a poll

Lol!

Dumbedore and Snape's death were essential. As much as it's saddening, it was needed. Dumbledore's death was planned, and it was a part of the plan to defeat Voldemort. It was also no one's choice but his. He knew it was the only way, and quite ironically, was the only one who even wanted to go through with it. That's a brave choice that he decided to make, and I admire him for it. He did the right thing. Everyone is obviously saddened because of his death, including me, but is it really fair to say we feel bad for him?

Let me rephrase: Is it true that we feel bad for him, or are we just saddened by his death? There's a big difference.

Nix... your papragraphs...

Tbh i did read them and yeah, thier deaths were needed for Voldemort's defeat. That doesn't make them any less sad though.

Oh, I sould have but Sirius in here.

Being saddened by someone's death is much different than feeling bad for the person. I wasn't saying that his death being essential made it less sad, I'm saying that feeling bad for him about a choice he decided to make isn't nessacarily the same as feeling sad that he died.

Sirius is a different story, it's not like Sirius planned his death or wanted to die; he was murdered. However, with Dumbledore it's a completely different case.

That's true.