Also they aren't going of the movies, they are drawing them how they imagined them in their head

I like to first 2 ones

Last one obviously has Bill

I mean come on!!!

The scars look very much alike

See?

Dude, that's what the artist drew, and also... THEY AREN'T GOING OFF THE MOVIES!!!!!!!

I’m still pretty sure it’s Bill

It looks so much like Bill

Wait...

Who is the artist?

Maybe we can ask the artist who it supposed to be...

Oh don’t know if I mentioned this but, book never said Lupin has freckles, but Bill does!!!

Here you go, what more evidence do you need