I'm torn.

Phoenixes are my fave magical aniamals, but I still think that Centaurs are intresting

Yes, plus what they did to Umbridge was incredible. They actually managed to shut her up for a while. The methods that are implied are a bit... disturbing though.

While I like phoenixes more, I must say I like the book centaurs better than the movie centaurs.

I've always found phoenixes really interesting 👀

Both are super pog honestly, but a Phoenix is flippin epic