Say if you were Albus Dumbledore and you've just had a meeting with James and Lily telling them that their infant son and entire family have been marked for death, how would you have dealt with the whole secret keeper business with them?
I’d probably do what Dumbledore did. I’d offer to be secret keeper, but respect their choice to pick who they trust.
Offer my enemy to be secret keeper and WHY ARE THERE SO MANY TAGS
You’re saying Lily and James should have chosen Voldemort as their secret keeper? I can see some flaws in that plan.
No, just a rival that’s non leathal
Like his brother
What do you think?