Battle of Hogwarts, and here are my reasons:
Slytherin Gang- A bit boring to do a RP just for boys (even though I am what you could call a Riddlevore)
Marauders- We already have one
Slytherin gang x Marauders- Same as above
First Year at Hogwarts- Same as above
Love in Hogwarts-You can do that in every single RP
So that's why I chose BoH