All posts by BLUEWHALEKITTEN

Happy Birthday to Harry James Potter 😁

I am currently writing a small fanfic, and wanted to know if I could post it on here, since I don’t have a watt pad or Ao3 account :)

Thank you

So when Sirius died, he fell into the veil, and that’s what technically killed him.

When a body is destroyed, the soul is released, allowing it to travel into the afterlife or whatever.

But since Sirius had a strange death, and Luna could hear voice coming from behind the veil, what if that’s where Sirius soul was trapped?

Think about it. It technically destroys the body, leaving the soul trapped inside.

What if, (against my other post about the resurrection stone) the way he was freed was from Harry bringing his memory from the resurrection stone?

But what if his soul had to return to the veil? If he was really struck, that would explain all the whispering. Luna and Harry are the only ones that can see thestrals, and so they are the only ones that can hear the whispering, explaining the voices to be souls, possibly crying out for help.

Holy I just re read this maybe I shouldn’t post about dark theory’s at 2:55 am

This one is kinda sad :(

And long so please bear with me 🙏

So most of us know that Sirius Black died, right? But before he did, he gave Harry a gift. The shard of mirror.

Fifth year was kinda hectic. Early on, Harry disappointed Sirius by turning down all his DA location suggestions and by saying it was too risky to talk to him. So why didn’t he use the mirror?

He refused to unwrap it. Sirius gave the mirror to Harry saying it would let him contact him if he ever wanted to talk or anything. That would have made fifth year so much easier.

But harry didn’t. He said it was ‘too risky’ to talk to Sirius using fire, and without Sirius knowing he didn’t unwrap the mirror, does that mean he thought that Harry just didn’t want to talk to him?

And then sirius died. Without ever knowing that Harry didn’t unwrap the mirror.

Did that mean that he died thinking Harry didn’t want to talk to him?

If so, he still tried. He gave Harry the mirror, the knife, and still, against Dumbledore’s will, rushed to help him when he was in trouble.

Harry never returned any of that. It kind of reminds me of that one line in the song ‘Youngblood.’ I give and I give and I give and you take.

Their relationship was so complex, yet they still cared for each other. But Sirius may have died thinking Harry was angry at him and didn’t want to talk to him.

Sorry It’s so long, my next post will be in the Sirius black topic too :)

If you read this entire thing, thank you!

Spoiler Alert!!

I’m back already!!

This theory is very dark, so be warned :)

In fifth year, Fred and George shove Montauge into the vanishing cabinet to stop him from taking points off Gryffindor.

In sixth year, we learn that Draco talked to Montauge and that’s where he got the idea to bring death eaters in through the cabinet from.

If there was no other possible way, and I mean NO OTHER WAY to bring death eaters into hogwarts, wouldn’t that make Fred and George indirectly responsible for Dumbledore’s death?

Because if they hadn’t shoved Montauge into the cabinet, then Draco wouldn’t have been able to bring death eaters into hogwarts, and then Draco would have accepted Dumbledore’s protection and Dumbledore could have died peacefully due to his hand and before then due to natural causes

Im not saying that snape couldn’t have gone and killed his before, but at least there wouldn’t have been death eaters.

Draco could have gone to the good side.

Snape could have been explained everything and not had been seen as a bad guy until after his death.

Its all a chain, and Fred and George may have started it.

Not sorry

Time for another random theory!

So… time turners

We know that in the cursed child that they find a time turner that allows them to travel back years into the past, but only stay there for five minutes.

With a regular time turner, you can only go a few hours back into the past and have to stay the entire time until time catches up to you again.

Or is it?

We also know that time turners were severely restricted by the ministry.

And if the two kinds of time turners are similar, how hard would it be to remove that part that restricts going back on the normal one?

This theory is a lot more tame than my last one, but here it is:

Time turners are so restricted by the ministry because it would be fairly easy to modify them to make them allow you to go back further, which would cause much more chaos (we saw what happened in the cursed child + they do have magic so how hard could it be?)

Kinda tame but I promise to post darker theories and I’m trying to keep them in the range that it could be possible

So we know that the resurrection stone brings back a shadow of a person so you can talk to them… right?

But what if death had really tricked the second brother. We know that he committed suicide after not being able to handle that image of the girl he wanted to marry. What if that was deaths intent?

And like… Harry’s mom sacrificed herself to save him, so why was she suddenly all chill with him dying? And why was everyone else that sacrificed themself?

So here’s my theory: the resurrection stone doesn’t actually bring back a shadow of the person, it creates a version of them that will do whatever they think will make you want to die.

Why else would everyone who literally just died for Harry suddenly want him to die? What if that was deaths sneaky intent in the first place?

Let me know what you think!

So we know that the resurrection stone brings back a shadow of a person so you can talk to them… right?

But what if death had really tricked the second brother. We know that he committed suicide after not being able to handle that image of the girl he wanted to marry. What if that was deaths intent?

And like… Harry’s mom sacrificed herself to save him, so why was she suddenly all chill with him dying? And why was everyone else that sacrificed themself?

So here’s my theory: the resurrection stone doesn’t actually bring back a shadow of the person, it creates a version of them that will do whatever they think will make you want to die.

Why else would everyone who literally just died for Harry suddenly want him to die? What if that was deaths sneaky intent in the first place?

Let me know what you think!