Talk: Death Eater defectors

Delete Narcissa Malfoy?

Should we delete Narcissa? She technically wasn't truly a Death Eater. minicurls the awesome (talk) 22:48, May 15, 2013 (UTC)

Should Peter be here he only hesitated to kill Harry he never truly defected DarthInvictus66

I personally think that Peter should not be on here, and neither should Narcissa. Peter hesitated for a second and was killed because of it - hesitation does not equal desertion. With Narcissa, she had pro-pure-blood ideals, but was never a Death Eater. It’s quite hard to defect from an organisation you were never a member of. It’s the same with the Black family - only Regulus joined, but he also defected, but the rest of his family, besides his cousin Bellatrix, did not join, but they believed in the cause. Narcissa believed in the cause (for a while) but never joined. TheTARDISLegilimens (talk) 17:29, October 23, 2017 (UTC)

Narcissa is clearly out as JKR has said she was never a Death Eater. Petigrew is a bit more unclear, could go either way. Probably best not to be in the category as no way to note the vagueness of his status. Cheers --Ironyak1 (talk) 18:52, October 23, 2017 (UTC)