|
Discussion[]
I don't know how talk pages work, so I apologize in advance if I do this wrong. Iris is not Hana. Unless some update has been released to Hogwarts Mystery that makes it so Tulip no longer mentions her grandmother Hana, or a staff member from the game developers said Hana no longer exists than she is still one of Tulip's grandmother. Both Mary and Rosa are described with the surname Karasu, which implies they are both Tulip's paternal grandmothers, either by them being a couple or by an unnamed grandfather Karasu marrying one and than later married the other, which leaves Tulip room for a maternal grandmother who is Hana. Until a source is shown to say Hana no longer exists which neither here nor Tulip's page provided, Hana, Rosa, and Mary are all Tulip's grandparents. I do not know how to restore Hana's page so if the one who deleted it could restore it and remove her content from aunt Iris' page that would be appreciated. ~Rosie. Geee
- If you think there is incorrect information that needs updating, you can edit it yourself. Also, if you don't understand how talk pages work, read this. - Peregino (talk) 14:44, 26 March 2024 (UTC)
Dear Peregino, 1) I think there has been a misunderstanding, the link you provided leads to the Talk Page Policy, which explains what is not allowed on talk pages but not how to actually use it. 2) I have made minor edits in the past, usually just one letter grammatical errors, but in my original message I said that I do not know how to undelete a page that no longer exists. Hana's page either is just gone now or was merged with Iris' page, neither of which I don't know how to undo. If you want me to be the one to correct this error I will, but I'll need you are someone else with enough knowledge to write a step by step instruction on how to fix it as again I do not know how. I hope you are having a pleasant day. - Rosie. Geee (talk) 19:08, 26 March 2024 (GMT-3)
- Hello Rosie. This is very insightful and perspicacious. There are a lot of possibilities for somebody to have three grandmothers (including the confirmation that gay marriage existed in the wizarding world as far back as the 1890s), but on this wiki we ultimately consider this level of "theorising" to be speculation, and it should not be put onto articles. If you think Tulip should have three grandmothers on her family members list, I would support that, but do not make any attempt to justify, explain, or elaborate beyond what we already know. I agree that Hana should be classed as having existed. The reason we did not make a page on Hana for so long is because she is so infrequently mentioned that there was not much to go on. Remember that anybody can contribute to this wiki and you are welcome to make edits within reason. :-) Castlemore (talk) 23:50, 26 March 2024 (UTC)
Dear Castlemore, what you say is reasonable and with what you said in mind I think it is fine for Hana to not have her own page. However there is no evidence currently provided that suggests Hana was intended to be the same character as Aunt Iris, that would also be SPECULATION. So may I have permission to remove "Aunt Iris was originally supposed to be one of Tulip's grandmothers, Hana. However, Hana was turned into Aunt Iris once Rosa Karasu and Mary Karasu were created." from Iris' trivia. That seems like a fair compromise. Hope that you too are having a nice day - Rosie. Geee (talk) 21:10, 26 March 2024 (GMT-3)